Ask The 'Diamond Guy®' - Fred Cuellar Ask The Diamond Guy®
Every day Fred Cuellar answers questions about diamonds. Why? Because he’s one of the world's most renowned experts on the subject of diamonds. So you can ask a question here if you cannot find it in the database. Questions are not answered immediately. It may take some time for your question to be answered. When it is answered, you will receive an email notifying you and a link to the answer.

Diamond Value Appreciation

Topic: Other


In late December 1999, I purchased a magnificent Hearts on Fire diamond ring for my wife – .773 Carat, EVS1, Cut Ideal. I paid $7,650 plus sales tax. In February 2001, after being unemployed for 1 year, we decided to sell the ring. Unfortunately, the jeweler who sold us the ring said that because of slow sales, he couldn’t buy it back right now. As a result, I went to another jeweler to see if he’d be interested in buying it. When he told me that I’d be lucky to get $4-5k, which he wasn’t willing to give me, I became alarmed and took the ring to a second jeweler for an informal appraisal. This jeweler told me that they wouldn’t sell my ring brand-new for more than $6,100. When confronted with my findings, the jeweler I bought the ring from told me diamonds depreciate just like cars – a diamond depreciates the day you take it home. What?!?! Also, he told me to name any product where you can get 2/3 of the purchase price after a period of time. Again, what?!?! I only had the ring for just over 1 year. And I realize that my diamond is not bonded so there is no guaranteed, fixed appreciation rate per annum. However, I was always under the assumption that gemstones, especially diamonds, appreciated in value unless, of course, it’s a low quality diamond. Who’s right? By the way, the situation got uglier when I found out, after some more digging, that they misrepresented the HOF diamond which induced me to buy it. As a result, I sent a complaint to the owner and asked for a full refund in exchange for my returning the ring. The owner sent me a nasty reply and basically said no way. I contacted the Better Business Bureau, but their correspondences to him did not waver his position. If you’d like, I can e-mail my complaint to you for your review and advice. Also, if intertested, I can fax their response to you – I don’t have it in an electronic format so I can’t e-mail it to you. Thanks for your help in sorting all this out. Take care and have a great week.



Hi Mike,

Good diamonds don’t depreciate! Heres what I need, all the facts and paperwork on your diamond that you have. Plus all the responses or letters you’ve received from the jeweler or BBB.

The Diamond Guy